General Enquiries : +65 6344 0224

A worker, not a slave: domestic workers still denied weekly rest days

Sally, a migrant domestic worker (MDW) from the Philippines, accepted a contract without any rest days because her agent told her that if she rejected the offer she might not get another one. Sally stayed with her employer for almost two years, working from 5:30am to 10pm every day. She wasn’t allowed to rest during the day, and only allowed to go outside to buy groceries. Eventually, the situation got too much for her to bear and, at her neighbour’s suggestion, she found her way to HOME.

When we first met Sally, she was exhausted. She was also very depressed. “It’s important to have a day off, to have time to make friends because it can be very lonely when you are overseas and away from your family,” she told HOME.

In January 2013, the Singapore government passed a legislation that mandates a weekly rest day for MDWs or compensation of a day’s wages in lieu. Despite this, a large percentage of MDWs work without any rest days. A study conducted by TWC2  in late 2013, early 2014 revealed that about 59% of the 192 domestic surveyed did not have a weekly day off and 40% who did have a weekly day off did not receive compensation in lieu. Another study conducted by HOME found that 40% of 670 domestic workers did not have a weekly day off.

While the legislation mandates that workers are given rest days, it is difficult for them to exercise this right because it doesn’t take into account the differences in negotiating power of both parties. Many women are pressured into accepting contracts with no rest days, particularly the new arrivals.

Those who arrive on such contracts tell us there is no negotiation: agents simply present them with “no rest day contracts” and their only “choice” is to either accept these terms or not get the job. As a result such workers arrive in Singapore “locked into” contracts with no rests days, or only one or two rest days a month. These contracts factor in very small amounts of financial compensation in lieu of rest days as a part of the total monthly wage amount. As Singapore does not set minimum wage guidelines for domestic workers, they are often pressured to accept this monetary trade-off for having no/few rest days, without which their monthly wages would be even lower.

At other times, even after signing a contract with rest days allocated, workers may find themselves being coerced by their employers into foregoing them, with or without additional compensation. For instance, a domestic worker whom we assisted had signed a contract guaranteeing one rest day week. Once she started work, her employer told her that she wouldn’t be receiving any. She did not object at the time for fear of being terminated. Her fears were came true four months later when, tired and lonely, she asked her employers for a weekly rest day: her employers responded by cancelling her work permit and attempted to repatriate her.

The current rest day legislation is also problematic because it does not specify the duration of their rest day. This omission leaves domestic workers vulnerable to the demands of their employers. A focus group conducted by HOME in April this year revealed that among those MDWs who were given rest days, all had to perform a range of household chores before they left the home and after they returned. For one worker, this left only six hours of time off between 11am–5pm (this also included time traveling to and from the home).

The provision of rest days is a basic human right that should be accorded to every worker. Having a full rest day allows them to catch up on sleep, de-stress, take time for themselves and/or socialize with others outside their workplace. As many workers told us during the focus group, it also gives them a chance to experience Singapore, to take in new sights and taste new foods.

In HOME and TWC2’s recently submitted shadow report to the UN’s Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) Committee, we called for the Singapore government to uphold its CEDAW obligations by passing legislation to better safeguard the right of domestic workers to a rest day. The government should disallow the practice of agents/employers pressuring domestic workers into contracts that trade off their right to a rest day. Rather, they should be able to negotiate with their employer whether or not to forego their rest day during the term of their employment. This should be an ongoing process and not predetermined at a point where workers are particularly vulnerable to being pressured to sign contracts with exploitative conditions. Additionally, domestic workers who are terminated by their employers for asserting their right to a weekly day off should be allowed to change employers. We also suggested that a provision should be inserted into the Employment of Foreign Manpower Act to ensure domestic workers receive at least eight continuous hours of rest per night and weekly rest days should be 24 hours.

 

 

6 Comments

  • Jen says:

    Many helper is the same like in her shoes….. though I have offday I still need to do may daily routine during off. I use to cook breakfast , lunch and cook dinner after my offday. . I even handwash and clean the house before leaving. I use to go out 1pm to 9pm. . I also produce my own mattress and buying my own toiletries.
    Sometimes I buy my own food.
    I hope and wish that some officers will make a surprise visit to such houses ..

  • Angelina Cauilan says:

    Yes i hope the employers knows their responsibility because most of them they just give us limited time of off day and once a month only

  • Maia basconcillo says:

    Thanks home it should be 24hours off day but for me i go out 10am untill 6pm so unfair some more everytime i go out they check on my bag and count my money i got nothing to say i feel like humilated then come back check again my things theres no.privacy

  • Melanie Alia Bescocho says:

    Yah my rest day also is only twice a month.. This is my second contract with them aldy.. On first contract it is stated there that only have 2 offdays a month. Then when my second contract started last year november, they never give me a copy of my contract , then only a week ago they just give me a copy and its stated there that im intitled to have a weekly offday.. So meaning they hide my contract for me not to know that im aldy given a weekly offday.. What the heck is that?? Then they also never give the compensation the two sundays that i dont tAke off..

  • Lilia says:

    Im so thankfull from up above for having a very good employers,
    My concern is my neighboor in our condo 04-06 shes buying her own food,and always going to her madam’s mother house to help them clean with out any compensation, we always share her food. Hope all this kinds of employer must be given a punishment.

  • Mar Quez says:

    Off day means no work for hsw like me,but the truth is we need to prepared breakfast for them before we leave and wash dishes and prepared food for dinner.If we will not do,who will do?Is this a so called off day?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *